Kalimah Allah: Pakatan Rakyat – PAS, PKR & DAP To “Agree To Disagree”?


Yes, this is my question.

I supposed, many are following closely to what is happening for the past few weeks, and particularly these past few days.

As the development is updated mainly by responses of PAS, PKR & DAP leaders in regards to can or not the translation of God to Allah (instead of “Tuhan”), we can see mixed reactions ever since PAS’ Syura Ulama Council made their announcement few days ago.

The significant responses to me would be from TG Nik Aziz and DS Jamil Khir that suggested that this matter should be closed and no dispute should be made further.

HOWEVER…

It seems the decision made by government and PAS is not agreeable by PKR and DAP. The “Yes” announcement made by TG Hj Hadi made earlier is being hold firm, without PKR muslim member really understood the “don’t abuse” clause. They just hold firm on the “Yes” decision, but not taking the later part of the announcement.

[ODS Note: This is the dangerous part of being indirect “No” when firm decision is very much needed. There will be those who will cut and paste partially of the decision to fit their own purpose. I do hope that by now TG Hj Hadi and PAS members will learn from this incident.]

It seems, as at now, PKR and DAP do not accept the verdict made by PAS Syura Ulama Council, in which is regard by TG Nik Aziz as the same level as mufti. I have asked this through twitter to Azmin Ali and some other Pakatan Rakyat leaders:

What is the higher council to advise on Islamic matter in Pakatan Rakyat???

However, until now, I have not receive any feedback, or even any indicator from the news, especially from proPR media. I sincerely hope someone can clarify on this matter.

So.. what’s left?

I supposed, one of the options left, (unless PAS change their stand and succumb to fellow PR’s pressure) is the very much famous stand of PR in Islamic matters – “Agree to disagree”.

Just do remember, in regards to hudud, it is more towards application of rule of law for Malaysians to live. However, this “Allah” word translation issue is religious issue, that touch the faith of muslim and christians. This not about law or rule of what is the punishment of wrong doing.. this is about faith and beliefs.

So.. how PAS, DAP and PKR is going to go about this?

I do hope there will be a firm decision. I am very much hoping this issue is closed. I am praying there will be no “agree to disagree” as this will bring more harm to Pakatan Rakyat to be as trusted government in a long run. A decision of “agree to disagree” may work well as an opposition, whereby no responsibilities held for any decision made.

Remember, as Opposition can say anything, but the burden will fall on government of the day. So, if Pakatan Rakyat do really serious of being government, act like one. I believe, day by day, nearer to GE13, Malaysians also want to see how capable PR is as government. That is why, most of the time, whenever and wherever, people also will ask PR’s view on things.

So.. what it will be?

Question on the street: Ever since PAS’ prayer of “BN KO” in their last Muktamar, PAS have been tested with tests, especially on religious matters… is it a sign or a test for PAS to get closer or further than Allah?

About these ads

2 responses to “Kalimah Allah: Pakatan Rakyat – PAS, PKR & DAP To “Agree To Disagree”?

  1. KATAKAN YANG HAK WALAUPUN PAHIT.

    Assalamualaikom wbr.

    Surat Mantan Naib Canselor Universiti Malaya Prof. Datuk Dr Hashim Yaacob bertajuk “Sesungguhnya-engkaulah-anak-kepada-Allah” kepada Utusan Malaysia bertarikh 17 Jan 2013 di rujuk

    Pertama sekali saya ingin mengucapkan syabas kerana Prof. Datuk sanggup membuka bible dalam membincangkan isu akidah yang sungguh penting ini, sesuatu yang mungkin belum di lakukan oleh Mufti atau Ustaz apabila mengupas isu ini. .

    Saya tidak bercadang untuk mempertikaikan kajian separuh masak yang telah di lakukan oleh Prof. Datuk kerana memang tetap sekali dan tidak dapat di nafikan, majority Krisitian mempercayai sebagaimana yang Prof. Datuk nyatakan.

    Apa yang Prof.Datuk nyatakan bukan sahaja berlaku di Malaysia hari ini tetapi telah berlaku lebih 1433 tahun yang lalu.

    Allah utusnya Nabi Muhammad s.a.w untuk membetulkan amalan syirik tersebut dengan turunnya surah Al Ikhlas dan ayat ayat lain;

    “Katakanlah (wahai Muhammad): (Tuhanku) ialah Allah Yang Maha Esa.Allah Yang menjadi tumpuan sekalian makhluk untuk memohon sebarang hajat.Dia tiada beranak dan Dia pula tidak diperanakkan Dan tidak ada sesiapapun yang serupa denganNya.” Al Ikhlas

    Termasuk ayat yang menemplak mereka yang mengatakan Al Masih itu Allah.

    “Demi sesungguhnya, kafirlah orang-orang yang berkata: “Bahawasanya Allah ialah Al-Masih Ibni Maryam) katakanlah (wahai Muhammad): “(Dakwaan itu tidak benar) kerana siapakah yang dapat menahan (seksa) dari Allah sedikit jua pun kalau Ia mahu membinasakan Al-Masih Ibni Maryam beserta ibunya dan orang-orang yang ada di muka bumi semuanya?” Dan (ingatlah) bagi Allah jualah kuasa pemerintahan langit dan bumi dan segala yang ada di antara keduanya. Ia menciptakan apa jua yang dikehendakiNya. Dan (ingatlah) Allah Maha Kuasa atas tiap-tiap sesuatu. (Al-Maaidah 5:17)

    Akan tetapi sebagai seorang Islam kita jangan lupa peringatan Allah seperti berikut:

    “Janganlah disebabkan kebencian kamu kepada sesuatu kaum menyebabkan kamu tidak berlaku adil. Berlaku adillah kamu kerana ia lebih hampir kepada taqwa.”

    Ingin saya mendapat penjelasan, apakah niat atau motifnya Prof. Datuk, meninggalkan ajaran para Nabi Musa dan Nabi Isa dan para Ambia’ yang begitu jelas tertulis dalam bible tu.

    Bukankah ajaran Nabi Nabi ini mengajak mengtauhidkan Allah, Tuhan yang maha Esa, tiada berbeza dengan Akidah yang di ajar oleh junjungan kita Nabi Muhammad s.a.w?

    Apakah ketika membuat kajian Prof. Datuk tak berjumpa ayat ayat di bawah:

    1. Then one of the scribes came, and having heard them reasoning together, perceiving that he had answered them well, asked him, “Which is the first commandment of all?” Jesus answered him, “The first of all the commandments is: ‘Hear, O Israel, the LORD our God, the LORD is one. And you shall love the LORD your God with all your heart, with all your soul, with all your mind, and with all your strength.’This is the first commandment. And the second, like it, is this: ‘You shall love your neighbour as yourself.’There is no other commandment greater than these.” (Mark 12:28-31)

    2. But when the Pharisees heard that he had silenced the Sadducees, they gathered together. Then one of them, a lawyer, asked Him a question, testing Him, and saying, “Teacher, which is the great commandment in the law?” Jesus said to him, ” ‘You shall love the LORD your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.’ This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it: ‘You shall love your neighbour as yourself.’ On these two commandments hang all the Law and the Prophets.” (Matthew 22:34-40)

    3. “Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God, the LORD is one! You shall love the LORD your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your strength.” (Deuteronomy 6:4-5)

    4. “.. the devil took him to a very high mountain and showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their splendor. 9 “All this I will give you,” he said, “if you will bow down and worship me. Jesus said to him, “Away from me, Satan ‘Worship the Lord your God, and serve him only.” ( Matthew 4:9-10)

    5. And this is eternal life, that they may know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You have sent (John17:3)

    6. And Jesus answered and said unto him, Get thee behind me, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.(Luke:4:8)

    7. “The most important one,” answered Jesus, “is this: ‘Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one. (Mark 12 : 29)

    Allah telah mewahyukan Al Quran yang merakamkan kisah kisah benar para Nabi dan Ambia yang telah di selewangkan oleh penulis penulis bible.

    Dan (ingatkanlah mereka wahai Muhammad), ketika Nabi Musa berkata kepada kaumnya: “Wahai kaumku! Kenanglah nikmat Allah (Yang diberikan) kepada kamu ketika Ia menjadikan dalam kalangan kamu beberapa orang Nabi, dan Ia menjadikan kamu bebas merdeka (setelah kamu diperhamba oleh Firaun dan orang-orangnya), dan Ia memberikan kepada kamu barang yang tidak pernah diberikan kepada seseorang pun dari umat-umat (yang ada pada masa itu)”. (Al-Maaidah 5:20)

    Sebelum menutup, hanya satu soalan untuk Prof. Datuk.

    Apakah hukumnya sekiranya ada mereka yang segaja menyembunyikan yang hak, hingga menyebabkan kekeliruan umat, hingga sanggup mengajak membakar Bible yang ada Allah di dalamnya?

    Marilah kita kembalilah mengamalkan ajaran murni Al Quran dan contoh yang di tunjukkan oleh ArRasul rahmatan fil alamin semakin diabaikan.

    “Katakanlah: Hai Ahli Kitab, marilah (berpegang) kepada suatu kalimah (ketetapan) yang tidak ada perselisihan antara kami dan kamu, bahawa tidak kita sembah kecuali Allah dan tidak kita persekutukan Dia dengan sesuatu pun dan tidak (pula) sebahagian kita menjadikan sebahagian yang lain sebagai tuhan selain Allah. Jika mereka berpaling maka katakanlah kepada mereka: “Saksikanlah, bahawa kami adalah orang-orang yang berserah diri (kepada Allah)”. (Ali-Imran : 64)

    Semuga Allah mengampunkan dosa dosa dan kecuaian kita.

    Wassalam.

    Rujukan

    http://www.utusan.com.my/utusan/Forum/20130117/fo_01/Sesungguhnya-engkaulah-anak-kepada-Allah—Matthew-1433

  2. The khalimah Allah issue mainly affects those who have been using it without problems. Mainly Christian natives from Sabah and Sarawak.
    If left to PAS alone, they would have objected to it streneously. But because they are in PR, with PKR and DAP carrying the non-Malay votes, then they have been swaying back and fourth trying to ‘calm’ and quell the fears of the non-Muslims.
    IMHO, the issue is clear, PR, namely PAS, PKR and DAP is a convenient ally that came together AFTER the 12thGE. This clearly shows that thwy have no common objective before the previous election, and with the impending election choose to hide their faws.

    PAS have been silent on their lifelong ambition, which is to further ‘Islamise’ the country. Evident in how they run Kelantan, and how they are trying to change Kedah. PKR and DAP, silent too in objection, knowing well that if they do, the Rakyat can see their true colours.

    In 55years of ruling the country, BN had never imposed segregation policies, yet in 4 years, PAS is trying to change the national landscape.

    Level headed Malaysians must take notice of what PR is capable of, and see that they should only stay as opposition and never be given the realms of government, for the damage if they do will be irreversible!

You are part of people on the street. My opinion might not as good as yours. Come, please share your thoughts with us!!!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s